Posted by hcampersFL on 5/17/06 10:12pm
Msg #120614
American Idol...Spoiler alert
I am going to miss Elliot. I really liked him! My hubby says he will buy me his first album. Next week should be great with Kat and Taylor going up against each other.
b.
|
Reply by Blueink_CA on 5/17/06 10:36pm
Msg #120617
Elliot's gone? We here on the West Coast are still waiting....Kat has the best voice, yeah she's young but she should win it!!
|
Reply by LkArrowhd/CA on 5/17/06 10:41pm
Msg #120618
Re: American Idol...Spoiler alert- Thanks in case I fall
asleep and that is just what "Simon Said"
|
Reply by Dee_Fla on 5/17/06 10:50pm
Msg #120623
We missed it since I was so into LOST and Amazing Race. At least it was not Taylor. I forgot to vote last night...so I have to make sure I do next week. -dee
|
Reply by cyndi_ca on 5/18/06 8:30am
Msg #120658
Re: American Idol...Spoiler alert Thanks, I
fell asleep so I did not get to see the results. Made my daughter go to bed and I was worried I wouldn't be able to tell her who got voted out. I won't miss Elliot too much. Kat IMO is the clear front runner.
|
Reply by celeste/ca on 5/18/06 9:40am
Msg #120681
Re: American Idol...Spoiler alert Thanks, I
I never cared for Elliot. I think Taylor will win only because he has a huge fan base, but as far singing, Kathryn has a better voice for an American Idol winner. I have always been a Taylor fan and I do like his soul patrol voice.
|
Reply by cyndi_ca on 5/18/06 10:26am
Msg #120695
Yes Celeste, I'd have to agree with you, however
I have to look at it as who's record would I buy. I dn't know if I would buy his.
|
Reply by db_IL on 5/18/06 10:35am
Msg #120701
Re: Yes Celeste, I'd have to agree with you, however
I guess I'm in the minority. I'll miss Elliott for sure. His soft, mild sensitivity was a refreshing offset to the quirky/bubbly bunch. Don't get me wrong if you're going for live entertainment Taylors 'seizure-like' moves are intriguing and Kathryn's fresh beauty are not to be denied. But since I'm a fool for a man who loves his momma - Elliott was my choice. But America has voted, who am I?
|
Reply by SLB SIGNING SERVICES, INC. - Sherry on 5/18/06 10:59am
Msg #120712
I was also sad to see Elliott go.....
IMHO I think that Elliott and Kathryn should have been the top 2 with Kathryn ultimately winning. Taylor has a great voice but he aggravates me with his antics. Its like a comedy/music/breakdance show all rolled into one with Taylor. He has a good voice but for me, his actions overshadow it.
On another note...Kathryn's rendition of Somewhere Over the Rainbow was absolutely breathtaking! Stil....All in all..I voted for Elliott to stay.
|
Reply by cyndi_ca on 5/18/06 11:02am
Msg #120714
Re: I was also sad to see Elliott go.....Sherry
Her rendition nearly brought me to tears. It reminded me of when Fantasia sang Summertime from Porgy and Bess. Truly moving.
|
Reply by SLB SIGNING SERVICES, INC. - Sherry on 5/18/06 11:05am
Msg #120715
Re: I was also sad to see Elliott go.....Sherry
I felt like I went back in time when I was listening to her.....I guess thats the mark of a true singer..when their singing can help you envision yourself somewhere other than on your couch, in your pjs, with dirty dishes in the sink and kids sneaking in and out of their beds...LOL
If only for a moment...AHHHHHHH...
|
Reply by cyndi_ca on 5/18/06 11:08am
Msg #120716
Re: I was also sad to see Elliott go.....Sherry
When a performer can take you "somewhere else" that is a sign of great talent.
|
Reply by SLP_VA on 5/18/06 2:45pm
Msg #120806
Re: I was also sad to see Elliott go.....Sherry
The percentages were so close! It could have been any of them.
So sad to see Elliot go. Especially since he's from my neck of the woods. Used to go to that pharmacy he used to work at a long time ago(although he wasn't there at the time). It wase CRAZY here when he came home.
I was hoping Chris and Elliot would be the bottom 2. Now I guess I won't be watching to see who wins since Tayor or Katherine were not my favorites at all. After Paris went, I was hoping those 2 would be next!
|
